A little over a year ago, we told you about a ridiculous law in South Carolina that provided for a sales tax "holiday" on purchases of handguns, rifles, and shotguns (later ruled unconstitutional for technical reasons, though only after the holiday had already taken place). Little did we know then that the idea would actually catch on. Louisiana enacted a similar "holiday" last month, upping the ante by exempting not only handguns, rifles, and shotguns, but also bows, crossbows, hunting knives, arrows, ammunition, rifle scopes, holsters, and much more. Unbelievably, the idea is reportedly receiving attention in Texas and Kentucky as well.
The Louisiana holiday is scheduled to occur each year on the first consecutive Friday through Sunday in September. During that weekend, neither state nor local sales taxes will be collected on a variety of items the legislature has declared worthy of being included in its "Second Amendment Holiday."
But it's not hard to imagine how many of those exemptions will pose serious administrative problems. With some exempt items, such as tree stands, there seems to be little room for confusion. In other cases however, the state has decided to exempt a variety of multi-purpose items based on whether they were designed, marketed, or even simply purchased for use while hunting (e.g. some items must be designed with hunting in mind, while others need only be purchased by somebody with the intent to hunt). Items falling into this category include off-road vehicles, animal feed, boots, bags, binoculars, chairs, belts, and various types of camouflage clothing.
Apparently, according to this list of tax-exempt items, you can look at a bird through tax-free binoculars, but only if you intend to kill it. Ensuring that these items are really purchased by individuals with "Second Amendment" intentions will no doubt prove impossible.
The bill's official fiscal note hints at a further complication involved with this holiday. Specifically, it explains that the state will pay retailers $25 for each cash register they re-program to calculate "Second Amendment" items as being tax-free. On top of that, the state will pay $25 more when the register is re-programmed, back to normal, at the end of the holiday. Official estimates are that it could cost Louisiana taxpayers up to $100,000 to help retailers make the necessary modifications. Since the holiday is only expected to result in $263,000 per year in tax savings, this $100,000 cost is not a trivial concern. And keep in mind, Louisiana taxpayers not purchasing weapons will be helping to pay this $100,000 tab to benefit their soon-to-be well-armed neighbors.
The inevitably complicated nature of sales tax holidays is just one of their many flaws -- as explained in this ITEP Policy Brief. But despite all their problems, at least typical "back-to-school" sales tax holidays can be interpreted as a misguided attempt to make life easier for families with school-age children. When it comes to these "Second Amendment Holidays," however, it's hard to see what exactly lawmakers are trying to gain, other than a pat on the back from the NRA.