In a move towards a more progressive tax structure, lawmakers in both Tennessee and South Carolina have floated plans to eliminate or reduce the sales tax on groceries. However, several competing proposals are under discussion in both states, and a political food fight of sorts has broken out.
In Tennessee, the Democrats in the House of Representatives have proposed a targeted food sales tax exemption for milk, eggs, and baby formula. Meanwhile, some Senate Republicans are lining up behind the bizarre idea of completely eliminating the state sales tax on groceries for a single month.
Tennessee's neighbor to the east is also grappling with various tax cut proposals. The South Carolina Senate Finance Committee passed a measure that would phase out the state sales tax on food over three years. The proposal is competing against a House measure that would reduce the top income tax rate.
Many have expressed concern over South Carolina's ability to pay for either measure, noting (wisely) that reducing revenues during a time of budget surpluses can lead to budget deficits down the road. There are ways to make tax breaks for food more targeted to those who need them the most (ways to get the most "bang for their buck" in other words). But almost any tax break on food would be more progressive than lowering the top income tax rate. For more on the best ways to target tax breaks to those who could really use them, read ITEP's policy brief on providing targeted tax relief for residents who need it the most.